Tata Punch EV vs MG Comet EV: Electric cars are becoming more popular and affordable in India, thanks to the government’s incentives and policies. Two of the most anticipated electric cars in the Indian market are the Tata Punch EV and the MG Comet EV. Both of them are compact hatchbacks that offer zero-emission mobility and low running costs. But which one is better for you? Let’s compare them on various parameters and find out.
Tata Punch EV vs MG Comet EV: Price
- Tata Punch EV: Starting at ₹10.99 lakh (ex-showroom)
- MG Comet EV: Starting at ₹7.98 lakh (ex-showroom)
The MG Comet EV is significantly cheaper than the Tata Punch EV, with a price difference of almost ₹3 lakh. This makes the Comet EV a more attractive option for budget-minded buyers. However, it’s important to note that the Punch EV comes with a larger battery pack and longer range, which we’ll discuss later.
Range and Battery
- Tata Punch EV: 380 km (claimed) with a 24.2 kWh battery pack
- MG Comet EV: 250 km (claimed) with a 17.3 kWh battery pack
The Tata Punch EV has a clear advantage in terms of range, thanks to its larger battery pack. This means you can travel further on a single charge with the Punch EV, making it a more practical choice for long journeys.
Power & Performance:
- Tata Punch EV: Boasts a permanent magnet synchronous motor churning out 87 bhp and 115 Nm of torque. Accelerates from 0-100 km/h in 10.5 seconds, reaching a top speed of 101 km/h.
- MG Comet EV: Features a less powerful AC induction motor generating 41 bhp and 110 Nm of torque. Takes 12 seconds to reach 100 km/h from a standstill, topping out at 80 km/h.
Winner on Power & Performance: Clearly, the Tata Punch EV takes the lead here. With almost double the horsepower and faster acceleration, it promises a more spirited driving experience.
Charging
- Tata Punch EV: Supports both AC and DC fast charging
- MG Comet EV: Supports only AC charging
The Tata Punch EV is again the more versatile option when it comes to charging. It supports both AC charging at home and DC fast charging at public charging stations. The MG Comet EV, on the other hand, only supports AC charging, which means it will take longer to top up the battery.
Fast charging, which could reduce its charging time to around an hour. The MG Comet EV does not support fast charging, and takes around 7 hours to charge fully using a regular AC socket.
Interior Dimensions
As we can see from the table, the Tata Punch EV has more cabin space, headroom, legroom, shoulder room, and seating capacity than the MG Comet EV. The Tata Punch EV can accommodate five passengers comfortably, while the MG Comet EV can only seat four passengers. The Tata Punch EV also offers more room for the passengers and the driver to stretch their legs, arms, and heads than the MG Comet EV.
| Dimensions | Tata Punch EV | MG Comet EV |
|---|---|---|
| Cabin Space (litres) | 2350 | 2000 |
| Headroom (mm) | 1000 | 980 |
| Legroom (mm) | 930 | 900 |
| Shoulder Room (mm) | 1320 | 1280 |
| Seating Capacity | 5 | 4 |
The larger interior dimensions of the Tata Punch EV mean that it has a more comfortable and spacious cabin than the MG Comet EV. The MG Comet EV, on the other hand, has a more cozy and futuristic cabin, with some unique features like a voice assistant, a 360-degree camera, and a smart key.
Exterior Dimensions
The exterior dimensions of a car include its length, width, height, wheelbase, ground clearance, and boot space. These dimensions affect the car’s road presence, stability, maneuverability, and luggage capacity. Here is a table that shows the exterior dimensions of the Tata Punch EV and the MG Comet EV:
| Dimensions | Tata Punch EV | MG Comet EV |
|---|---|---|
| Length (mm) | 3840 | 2974 |
| Width (mm) | 1724 | 1505 |
| Height (mm) | 1615 | 1640 |
| Wheelbase (mm) | 2450 | 2010 |
| Ground Clearance (mm) | 190 | 165 |
| Boot Space (litres) | 366 | 240 |
As we can see from the table, the Tata Punch EV is significantly larger than the MG Comet EV in every dimension, except for the height. The Tata Punch EV is 866 mm longer, 219 mm wider, 440 mm longer in wheelbase, 22 mm higher in ground clearance, and 126 litres more in boot space than the MG Comet EV. The only dimension where the MG Comet EV is slightly taller than the Tata Punch EV is the height, by 25 mm.
The larger dimensions of the Tata Punch EV mean that it has a more imposing road presence, a more stable ride, a better turning radius, and a more spacious boot than the MG Comet EV. The MG Comet EV, on the other hand, has a more compact and quirky design, which makes it easier to park and drive in congested city traffic.
Tata Punch EV vs MG Comet EV Ground Clearance: Which Electric Car Can Handle Rough Roads Better?
Ground clearance is the distance between the lowest point of a car’s body and the ground. It affects the car’s ability to handle rough roads, speed bumps, and potholes without scraping or damaging the underside. Higher ground clearance is usually preferred for Indian road conditions, as it offers more safety and comfort. In this article, we will compare the ground clearance of two upcoming electric cars in India, the Tata Punch EV and the MG Comet EV, and see which one can handle rough roads better.
Tata Punch EV Ground Clearance
The Tata Punch EV is based on the regular Tata Punch, which is a stylish and spacious hatchback. The Tata Punch EV have a ground clearance of 190 mm, which is quite impressive for a hatchback. It is also higher than the ground clearance of the regular Tata Punch, which is 187 mm. The Tata Punch EV’s high ground clearance means that it can easily tackle uneven roads, speed breakers, and waterlogged areas without any hassle. It also gives the car a more SUV-like stance and road presence.
MG Comet EV Ground Clearance
The MG Comet EV has a ground clearance of 165 mm, which is decent for a hatchback, but lower than the Tata Punch EV. The MG Comet EV’s low ground clearance means that it might face some difficulties while driving on rough roads, especially when fully loaded. It also gives the car a more sporty and aerodynamic look, but less imposing than the Tata Punch EV.
The Tata Punch EV and the MG Comet EV are both promising electric cars that offer different benefits to the buyers. The Tata Punch EV has a higher ground clearance than the MG Comet EV, which makes it more suitable for Indian road conditions. The MG Comet EV has a lower ground clearance than the Tata Punch EV, which makes it more agile and efficient, but less comfortable and safe. The choice between them depends on your budget, preferences, and needs. If you want a reliable and versatile electric car that can handle rough roads and city traffic, the Tata Punch EV is the better option. If you want a fun and compact electric car that can save you money and impress your friends, the MG Comet EV is the better option.
Features
- Tata Punch EV: Gets a touchscreen infotainment system, automatic climate control, connected car features, and a sunroof (top-end variant)
- MG Comet EV: Gets a touchscreen infotainment system, automatic climate control, and a panoramic sunroof (top-end variant)
Both cars come with a decent set of features, but the Tata Punch EV has a slight edge with its connected car features and sunroof (on the top-end variant).
Design
- Tata Punch EV: Rugged SUV-inspired design with a bold grille and high ground clearance
- MG Comet EV: Sleek and modern design with a focus on aerodynamics
The Tata Punch EV has a more traditional SUV-like design, while the MG Comet EV is more modern and aerodynamic. Ultimately, the design choice will come down to personal preference.
Safety
Both cars come with standard safety features such as ABS, EBD, and airbags. However, the Tata Punch EV gets additional features like traction control and hill hold assist, which could be helpful in certain driving conditions.
- Warranty: Tata Punch EV offers a 8 years or 1,60,000 km km warranty on the battery and motor, while MG Comet EV provides a 5-year/unlimited km warranty for the same.
- Service Network: Tata Motors has a wider service network in India compared to MG Motor, which might be important for some buyers.
Conclusion
The Tata Punch EV and the MG Comet EV are both promising electric cars that offer different benefits to the buyers. The Tata Punch EV is more expensive, but also more powerful, efficient, and practical. The MG Comet EV is cheaper, but also less capable, comfortable, and safe. The choice between them depends on your budget, preferences, and needs. If you want a reliable and versatile electric car that can handle long trips and city traffic, the Tata Punch EV is the better option. If you want a fun and funky electric car that can save you money and impress your friends, the MG Comet EV is the better option.